Gardasil Researcher Speaks Out - CBS News

archive.today
webpage capture

Saved from

history←prior next→ |

12 Jan 2020 21:19:24 UTC

All snapshots | from host www.cbsnews.com
Webpage Screenshot
share download .zip report bug or abuse donate

- Plane Crash In Iran
- Puerto Rico Earthquake
- Homeless Oakland Moms
- Travel Ban
- Neil Peart Dies
- Severe Weather
- Heroic Dog

Watch CBSN Live

# Gardasil Researcher Speaks Out

By Sharyl Attkisson
August 19, 2009 / 5:13 PM / CBS
Amid questions about the safety of the HPV vaccine Gardasil one of the lead researchers for the Merck drug is speaking out about its risks, benefits and aggressive marketing.
Dr. Diane Harper says young girls and their parents should receive more complete warnings before receiving the vaccine to prevent cervical cancer. Dr. Harper helped design and carry out the Phase II and Phase III safety and effectiveness studies to get Gardasil approved, and authored many of the published, scholarly papers about it. She has been a paid speaker and consultant to Merck. It's highly unusual for a researcher to publicly criticize a medicine or vaccine she helped get approved.
Dr. Harper joins a number of consumer watchdogs, vaccine safety advocates, and parents who question the vaccine's risk-versus-benefit profile. She says data available for Gardasil shows that it lasts five years; there is no data showing that it remains effective beyond five years.

#### Trending News

- Ship seized in massive drug bust is owned by JP Morgan Chase
- Another earthquake rocks quake-stunned Puerto Rico
- Bill Cowher inducted into Pro Football Hall of Fame
- At least 11 dead in dangerous winter storm heading across U.S.

Read Judicial Watch reports on Gardasil
Dr. LaPook's Story on HPV
Attkisson's Exclusive Report on Gardasil
This raises questions about the CDC's recommendation that the series of shots be given to girls as young as 11-years old. "If we vaccinate 11 year olds and the protection doesn't last... we've put them at harm from side effects, small but real, for no benefit," says Dr. Harper. "The benefit to public health is nothing, there is no reduction in cervical cancers, they are just postponed, unless the protection lasts for at least 15 years, and over 70% of all sexually active females of all ages are vaccinated." She also says that enough serious side effects have been reported after Gardasil use that the vaccine could prove riskier than the cervical cancer it purports to prevent. Cervical cancer is usually entirely curable when detected early through normal Pap screenings.
Dr. Scott Ratner and his wife, who's also a physician, expressed similar concerns as Dr. Harper in an interview with CBS News last year. One of their teenage daughters became severely ill after her first dose of Gardasil. Dr. Ratner says she'd have been better off getting cervical cancer than the vaccination. "My daughter went from a varsity lacrosse player at Choate to a chronically ill, steroid-dependent patient with autoimmune myofasciitis. I've had to ask myself why I let my eldest of three daughters get an unproven vaccine against a few strains of a nonlethal virus that can be dealt with in more effective ways."
Merck and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention maintain Gardasil is safe and effective, and that adequate warnings are provided, cautioning about soreness at the injection site and risk of fainting after vaccination. A new study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found while the overall risk of side effects appears to be comparable to other vaccines, Gardasil has a higher incidence of blood clots reported. Merck says it continues to have confidence in Gardasil's safety profile. Merck also says it's looking into cases of ALS, commonly known as Lou Gehrig's Disease, reported after vaccination. ALS is a progressive neurodegenerative disease that attacks motor neurons in the brain and spinal cord. Merck and the CDC say there is currently no evidence that Gardasil caused ALS in the cases reported. Merck is also monitoring the number of deaths reported after Gardasil: at least 32. Merck and CDC says it's unclear whether the deaths were related to the vaccine, and that just because patients died after the shots doesn't mean the shots were necessarily to blame.
According to Dr. Harper, assessing the true adverse event risk of Gardasil, and comparing it to the risk of cervical cancer can be tricky and complex. "The number of women who die from cervical cancer in the US every year is small but real. It is small because of the success of the Pap screening program."
"The risks of serious adverse events including death reported after Gardasil use in (the JAMA article by CDC's Dr. Barbara Slade) were 3.4/100,000 doses distributed. The rate of serious adverse events on par with the death rate of cervical cancer. Gardasil has been associated with at least as many serious adverse events as there are deaths from cervical cancer developing each year. Indeed, the risks of vaccination are underreported in Slade's article, as they are based on a denominator of doses distributed from Merck's warehouse. Up to a third of those doses may be in refrigerators waiting to be dispensed as the autumn onslaught of vaccine messages is sent home to parents the first day of school. Should the denominator in Dr. Slade's work be adjusted to account for this, and then divided by three for the number of women who would receive all three doses, the incidence rate of serious adverse events increases up to five fold. How does a parent value that information," said Harper.
Dr. Harper agrees with Merck and the CDC that Gardasil is safe for most girls and women. But she says the side effects reported so far call for more complete disclosure to patients. She says they should be told that protection from the vaccination might not last long enough to provide a cancer protection benefit, and that its risks - "small but real" - could occur more often than the cervical cancer itself would.
"Parents and women must know that deaths occurred. Not all deaths that have been reported were represented in Dr. Slade's work, one-third of the death reports were unavailable to the CDC, leaving the parents of the deceased teenagers in despair that the CDC is ignoring the very rare but real occurrences that need not have happened if parents were given information stating that there are real, but small risks of death surrounding the administration of Gardasil."
She also worries that Merck's aggressive marketing of the vaccine may have given women a false sense of security. "The future expectations women hold because they have received free doses of Gardasil purchased by philanthropic foundations, by public health agencies or covered by insurance is the true threat to cervical cancer in the future. Should women stop Pap screening after vaccination, the cervical cancer rate will actually increase per year. Should women believe this is preventive for all cancers - something never stated, but often inferred by many in the population-- a reduction in all health care will compound our current health crisis. Should Gardasil not be effective for more than 15 years, the most costly public health experiment in cancer control will have failed miserably."
CDC continues to recommend Gardasil for girls and young women. The agency says the vaccine's benefits outweigh its risks and that it is an important tool in fighting a serious cancer.
Dr. Harper says the risk-benefit analysis for Gardasil in other countries may shape up differently than what she believes is true in the US. "Of course, in developing countries where there is no safety Pap screening for women repeatedly over their lifetimes, the risks of serious adverse events may be acceptable as the incidence rate of cervical cancer is five to 12 times higher than in the US, dwarfing the risk of death reported after Gardasil."

### World

More
In World

#### Saudi service members to be expelled after Florida base shooting

The service members are not accused of involvement in the shooting, but some are said to be linked to extremist movements and a number are accused of possessing child pornography.

#### Protesters defy heavy police presence in Tehran

The head of the Revolutionary Guard's aerospace division said his unit accepts "full responsibility"

#### Trump warns Iranian leaders not to kill demonstrators

"To the leaders of Iran - DO NOT KILL YOUR PROTESTERS," the president tweeted.

#### In Sicily, police patrol for pistachio thieves

With the biennial harvest upon them, farmers of the valuable crop are getting assistance from Italy's paramilitary security force

#### Carlos Ghosn calls himself a "fugitive of injustice"

It's the caper that's captivated the world: the escape from Japan by the former Nissan executive accused of financial wrongdoing, who reportedly hid in a box to be flown out of the country
More in World

### U.S.

More
In U.S.

#### Saudi service members to be expelled after Florida base shooting

The service members are not accused of involvement in the shooting, but some are said to be linked to extremist movements and a number are accused of possessing child pornography.

#### Protesters defy heavy police presence in Tehran

The head of the Revolutionary Guard's aerospace division said his unit accepts "full responsibility"

#### John Kerry says Sanders is "distorting" Biden's record on Iraq War

The former secretary of state told "Face the Nation" accused Sanders of "distorting" Biden's record on the war in Iraq.

#### Senators say Congress to blame for not reining in use of military force

Senators Tim Kaine and Mike Lee blamed Congress for giving the president too much power to use military force.

#### Transcript: John Kerry on "Face the Nation"

The following is a transcript of an interview with Former Secretary of State John Kerry that aired Sunday, January 12, 2020, on "Face the Nation.
More in U.S.

### Politics

More
In Politics

#### John Kerry says Sanders is "distorting" Biden's record on Iraq War

The former secretary of state told "Face the Nation" accused Sanders of "distorting" Biden's record on the war in Iraq.

#### Senators say Congress to blame for not reining in use of military force

Senators Tim Kaine and Mike Lee blamed Congress for giving the president too much power to use military force.

#### Transcript: John Kerry on "Face the Nation"

The following is a transcript of an interview with Former Secretary of State John Kerry that aired Sunday, January 12, 2020, on "Face the Nation.

#### Schiff: Trump "fudging" intelligence to justify Soleimani strike

The House Democrat told "Face the Nation" that the president and other officials are "fudging" the intelligence about Iran.

#### Transcript: Sen. Mike Lee on "Face the Nation"

The following is a transcript of an interview with Senator Mike Lee that aired Sunday, January 12, 2020, on "Face the Nation.
More in Politics

### Entertainment

More
In Entertainment

#### Passage: Remembering Buck Henry

The comic writer and actor helped bring "Get Smart," "The Graduate" and "Heaven Can Wait" to the screen, and was a frequent guest host of "Saturday Night Live"

#### Passage: Buck Henry

The comic writer and actor Buck Henry, who helped bring "Get Smart," "The Graduate" and "Heaven Can Wait" to the screen, and who was a frequent guest host of "Saturday Night Live," died this past week at age 89. Jane Pauley reports. We also remember Rush drummer Neil Peart, who died this week at 67.

#### The art of Kim Novak

The star of such classics as Alfred Hitchcock's "Vertigo" and "Picnic" turned her back on Hollywood in the 1960s, exchanging a movie studio for an artist's studio

#### Sunday Profile: Kim Novak

Now on the cusp of turning 87, Kim Novak is still finding herself. The star of such classics as Alfred Hitchcock's "Vertigo," "Picnic," and "Bell, Book and Candle," the actress turned her back on Hollywood in the 1960s and has since pursued artwork and a love of animals. Mo Rocca reports.

#### Gary Clark Jr.: "Music is my religion"

At 35, heralded as one the best guitarists in a generation, he's played the White House, toured with The Rolling Stones and Eric Clapton, and is up for four Grammy Awards for his album "This Land"
More in Entertainment

### Technology

More
In Technology

#### Texas gamer saves friend having seizure 5,000 miles away

"I'm calling from the U.S. I'm currently on a call with my friend, he had a seizure and he's not responding anymore," 20-year-old Dia Lathora from Texas told Cheshire police in England over the phone.

#### Judge orders Google to turn over Jussie Smollett's data

Chicago judge approved two search warrants that would give access to files associated with the actor's Gmail address and location data.

#### Robots: Now coming to a workplace near you

An emerging generation of robots is leaving the lab to flip burgers, deliver packages and even perform surgery.

#### Tesla now America's most valuable car company

Electric car maker is worth more than Ford and General Motors — combined — even as it struggles to turn a profit.

#### Google speakers can "vacuum up" personal data, lawsuit says

Speaker company's suit echoes a growing number of antitrust complaints about Google's entering new markets.
More in Technology

### Science

More
In Science

#### Studying the creativity and intelligence of the octopus

It's one of the most bizarre life forms on Earth – one of the smartest, most interesting, and most alien, with eight more brains than you have

#### Teen discovers rare new planet 3 days into NASA internship

NASA's planet hunter satellite TESS has discovered an exoplanet orbiting two stars instead of one — and it was identified by a high school intern.

#### Leo DiCaprio's foundation donating $3 million to help Australia wildfires

Earth Alliance says it created a fund to help with an "international response to the catastrophic bushfires" raging in the country.

#### What scientists learned by putting 3D glasses on cuttlefish

The goal, other than having a reason to put cute little glasses on sea creatures, was to learn more about their depth perception.

#### Nature up close: The decline of the caribou

Despite their remarkable adaptability to an unforgiving environment, the numbers of these large, majestic, gentle-looking animals have fallen by more than half in the United States since 2003
More in Science

### Health

More
In Health

#### Texas gamer saves friend having seizure 5,000 miles away

"I'm calling from the U.S. I'm currently on a call with my friend, he had a seizure and he's not responding anymore," 20-year-old Dia Lathora from Texas told Cheshire police in England over the phone.

#### St. Boniface Hospital, a beacon of hope in post-quake Haiti

Basic medical care can be almost impossible to find on much of the island, but a teaching hospital in a hard-to-reach mountain community, surviving on private donations and grants, treats 500 patients a day, and turns no one away

#### Protein snack trays in 10 states recalled over listeria fears

Potentially tainted hard-boiled eggs prompts pulling of food products from convenience stores and vending machines.

#### Face mask that left girl's face "bright red" recalled

Natural ingredients in sheet masks are not always a good thing, Dermatologist Elizabeth Hale warns.

#### Lab finds new clues in Zantac's possible cancer link

Last fall the FDA said they had detected a "probable" cancer-causing chemical in the generic form of Zantac.
More in Health

### MoneyWatch

More
In MoneyWatch

#### Fighting for overdue protections for pregnant workers

Despite the law, many employers still deny accommodations to pregnant workers, forcing thousands of women out of their jobs, or making them face serious choices affecting careers and family

#### Boeing's new CEO to get $28 million pay package for 2020

David Calhoun pay package includes $7 million bonus for 737 Max's safe return to service.

#### Judge says real estate firm can evict homeless Oakland moms

Real estate investment firm that owns empty California home says squatters are "taking something from someone else."

#### Main Street investors beat world's largest hedge fund last year

Bridgewater's flagship fund made no money for its investors in 2019, while a simple S&P 500 index fund returned 31.5%.

#### Most U.S. jobs are now held by women

"Likely to be permanent," one expert says, as females dominate in growing industries like health care and education.
More in MoneyWatch

### Crime

More
In Crime

#### Saudi service members to be expelled after Florida base shooting

The service members are not accused of involvement in the shooting, but some are said to be linked to extremist movements and a number are accused of possessing child pornography.

#### Extradition request would be "inappropriate," U.S. official says

The State Department commented after the British authorities requested Anne Sacoolas' extradition.

#### Jail cell video of Epstein's first suicide attempt is lost: "This is madness"

The jail "inadvertently preserved video from the wrong tier," federal prosecutors said.

#### Jeffrey Epstein jail cell video missing

Missing video is raising new questions in the investigation of the federal jail cell death of convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. Federal prosecutors said yesterday video of Epstein’s jail cell when he made his first suicide attempt “no longer exists.” Epstein, who was accused of sexually abusing dozens of underage girls, died by suicide weeks later on August 10. Mola Lenghi reports.

#### Hanukkah stabbing suspect charged with more hate crimes

Grafton Thomas now faces 10 federal hate crime charges, each carrying a possible sentence of life in prison.
More in Crime

### Space

More
In Space

#### Teen discovers rare new planet 3 days into NASA internship

NASA's planet hunter satellite TESS has discovered an exoplanet orbiting two stars instead of one — and it was identified by a high school intern.

#### SpaceX launches more Starlink satellites

SpaceX launched its third batch of 60 internet relay satellites Monday night. It now has more satellites in orbit than any other company. CBSN's Vladimir Duthiers and Anne-Marie Green have details.

#### SpaceX's latest launch seeks to address astronomers' concerns

The launch boosts the number of Starlink internet relay satellites to 180 as SpaceX builds a vast constellation.

#### 2020 a big year for space exploration

SpaceX and Boeing are teaming up with NASA to send astronauts to space. CBS News space analyst Bill Harwood joins CBSN to discuss how 2020 will be a significant year in space exploration.

#### NASA astronaut Christina Koch sets a new record in space

Christina Koch passes Peggy Whitson's 288-day mark on Saturday to set a new record for longest single space flight by a female astronaut.
More in Space

### Latest Galleries

More
In Latest Galleries

#### Meghan Markle's style, from "Suits" to the royal family

Whatever's next for the the Duchess of Sussex, she's sure to do it in royal fashion.

#### Britain's royal line of succession

Does the announcement from the Duke and Duchess of Sussex change anything?

#### Australia wildfires: Animals in peril across the country

More than 1 billion animals are feared dead.

#### Crash course on Meghan Markle

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry are doing royalty their own way.

#### Australia fires: Pictures from the deadly wildfires

Millions of acres have already burned.
More in Latest Galleries

### Popular

More
In Popular

#### Popular

#### Tsai Ing-wen's landslide victory

Taiwan's incumbent President Tsai Ing-wen swept to a landslide victory in the country's election on Saturday. Isaac Stone Fish, a senior fellow at the Asia Society’s Center on U.S.-China Relations joined CBSN to discuss the impact of Tsai's win.

#### Worldwide effort to save Australia's animals

It's estimated that more than 1 billion animals have been killed in Australia's devastating wildfires. Jamie Yuccas reports from the fire zone on how the world is rallying to save the unique species.

#### Reporter's Notebook: Tensions in Iran

CBS News' Elizabeth Palmer gives an update on where things stand for the embattled regime.

#### Kerry pushes back against Trump: "The president's tweet is a lie"

The former secretary of state says he stands by the Obama administration's 2015 nuclear deal with Iran.

#### Kaine says Congress "stepping up to the plate" on new AUMF

The Virginia Democrat says Senate members of the Gang of Eight were unhappy with the intelligence they received this week.
More in Popular
View CBS News In

- CBS News App Open
- Chrome Safari Continue

0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%