Eva, Charlie, Sarah: part 3: birthday surprise
This takes place a couple of years later than part 2 of this series. As before, Charlie tells the story in first person.
Disclaimer: Charlie gets a good spanking, but otherwise this one is still pretty tame. Things are still developing. More in part 4!
Hi, Charlie here again. A quick recap of the characters from the previous parts. Eva was about two years older than me; I was finishing up high school and I had just turned 18, and Eva was finishing up her second year of nursing school. Eva lived at home, mostly alone as her parents were constantly traveling in Europe on business. I'd been friends with Eva for quite a few years, going back to our being on our high school Science Olympiad team together but our friendship was slowly evolving into more of a "girlfriend/boyfriend" relationship. Several things kept the development of our relationship on a slow track. Most importantly, we were both very serious about our schoolwork, we just weren't ready to have a committed relationship, and we felt that sex was best reserved for serious committed relationships. Also there was Sarah, Eva's best friend. The three of us had all become closer, and Eva and I were both worried that if we became a couple, Sarah would somehow feel left out or hurt. I would have considered myself the luckiest guy in my school to have either of these smart, beautiful young women as my girlfriend, but it did seem like Eva and I were really made for each other. Sarah and I were very friendly too, but things just didn't click in the same way between us.
Eva and Sarah both went to nursing school just across town. We live in a college town with a major public university with a huge teaching hospital that has nationally known medical, nursing, dental, pharmacy, and public health schools. Eva was thrilled to be accepted there, and living at home for her freshman year has really helped her family with the cost. Her aunt is a physician and manager of a group medical practice that is right across the street from the high school. Eva works part time there too, often after their closing hours, doing things like cleaning up, restocking supplies in the exam and treatment rooms, and getting charts and equipment ready for the next day. Sarah comes from a family with more financial problems, substantially due to her parents' long struggles with depression and alcohol. Fortunately Sarah had been awarded a very generous financial aid package, since she was both a top student and one with a very substantial need for assistance. Sarah spent as little time as possible with her parents, especially when they drank, so she mostly lived at Eva's house these days.
Since Eva and I had progressed to the girlfriend/boyfriend stage, we started to have serious "safe sex" talks. We were both very concerned about an unintended pregnancy. We agreed that we weren't going to have intercourse for the time being, but if the time came when we were ready, we would use two forms of birth control at all times to be safe. Eva confided in me that her aunt, the physician, had given her a prescription for birth control pills "just to have; to fill in the time came when she needed it", but that time hadn't come yet. I was more than ready (and horny as hell), but I respected Eva's cautious, go-slow approach. I loved her deeply and I knew she was well worth waiting for.
Despite our concerns about the possible impact on Sarah, Eva and I were gradually becoming more and more intimate when we had private time together. We'd kiss passionately and our hands were gently roaming all over each other more and more. A couple of times we got a little careless and got caught by Sarah squeezing and pawing each others asses while we kissed, but Sarah didn't seem jealous or hurt; she actually had a mischievous smile and she seemed amused about the whole thing. Eva and I would also have wrestling and tickling "fights" in her back yard, although I was bigger and stronger so Eva really didn't stand much chance. She'd invariably end up getting pinned down and thoroughly tickled by me, and she seemed to like it a lot. One time she mentioned that sometimes she wished she was strong enough to overpower me, since she thought I'd probably enjoy being at the receiving end of such treatment. Of course she was right, but we didn't get to discuss it as Sarah happened to show up. She had been quietly watching us (Sarah could at times be a voyeur, an exhibitionist, or both).
"Is poor Charlie sad he never gets pinned down and tickled? I could help!" Sarah pounced on me. She was by far the most athletic of the three of us; she could have easily overpowered me alone, but she demanded Eva join in too. With both of them all over me, I didn't stand a chance. I found myself flat on my back with Sarah straddling me and clamping me tightly between her strong, beautiful legs. I was completely helpless. Eva tickled me mercilessly, getting me back for all I had done to her. I loved it. When Eva got tired of tickling me, Sarah brought up something else. "Hey Charlie, we forgot one thing for your birthday." I had just turned 18 earlier that month. "What's that?", I asked mischievously; anything from these two was bound to be fun. "We never gave you your birthday spanking! Eighteen spanks from me and eighteen from Eva." I had no particular interest in pain or corporal punishment, but the thought of a spanking from these two sweeties appealed to all my prurient interests. Eva seemed hesitant. "Sarah, are you sure that isn't too mean." "Don't always be a teddy bear, Eva; look at the wicked grin on his face. He wants it and he wants it bad. Isn't that right, Charlie?" I blushed a little but nodded my head. "Say it Charlie." "Yes." "Yes what?" "Yes I'd like a birthday spanking from you two." As the words came out I turned bright red. But the three of us had become increasingly close and increasingly honest with each other; there was absolutely no point in lying, especially when they had me figured out like this.
I wasn't exactly in a position of strength for a discussion anyhow, as I was pinned flat on my back to the lawn, with Sarah straddling and sitting on my chest while Eva straddled and sat on my hips. I also had a growing erection that strained at my gym shorts; I wondered if Eva noticed as she was sitting directly on it. "We'll have to roll him over." Sarah and Eva both lifted themselves up to kneeling so I could move, but I was still effectively trapped between their legs. "Roll over!". I immediately obeyed. Sarah gently but firmly lowered herself back down onto my back, pinning me down again. She squeezed me between her legs. She was strong but also soft and warm. It felt really nice.
Eva seemed hesitant. "Does this mean I have to spank him first?" "I think you'd better; you're such a cuddly wuddly teddy bear, Eva; you'll probably just be a warm up. Then I'll give Charlie a real birthday spanking. You'll probably be too gentle to even wipe that smug grin off his face." I made no effort to conceal my enjoyment of the situation; they would have seen right through it anyhow. "We'll see about that." Eva's first swat caught me by surprise. "Ah!" I quickly stopped myself. This was a pretty hard one from Eva; I had expected less. I don't think Eva wanted to be outdone by Sarah; they were fiercely competitive on almost everything. "That's one!" Eva said loudly. I was glad her backyard was pretty private; you really couldn't see or hear anything there except from her house and mine, and both her parents and mine were traveling in Europe on business. I felt a second slap, a little harder, and heard "two" from Eva, then another and "three". Eva got to nine, half way, and she paused to see how I was doing. I had an obvious smile on my face; here I was lying comfortably on Eva's back yard getting worked over by two beautiful girls who I fancied considerably. Once of them had me tightly clamped between her legs while the other was swatting my behind. Who wouldn't smile? I guess my smile made some impression on Eva because the next one was quite a bit harder; it actually did sting a lot. "Ten!". She ramped it up even more more. "eleven" ... "twelve" ... "thirteen" ... "fourteen" ... "fifteen" ... "sixteen" ... "seventeen" ... "eighteen".
"My turn now; trade places", said Sarah. I made absolutely no attempt to escape as Sarah climbed off me and Eva took her place. Eva was much smaller and lighter than Sarah; if I had really wanted to get her off me I'm sure I could have, but why on earth would I want to? Distracted by Eva's warmth as she gently squeezed me between her legs and lowered her bottom onto my back, I was caught off guard. SMACK! "Owwww! "ONE!" SMACK! "TWO" SMACK! "THREE" "Sarah, I think that's too hard; we don't want to hurt him." The smile was gone from my face and these really did sting, but I was still enjoying the sensation. "Don't worry about Charlie, Eva; I'll bet he is enjoying every second of this." True, but I remained silent. "Tell you what, Sarah. I'll pause after each whack to give him a chance to beg for mercy." WHACK! "FOUR! Do you hear him begging, Eva; I'm not hearing anything." The smile had come back to my face. "OK, Sarah; he's just as naughty as you; you were right; I think he's liking this." Guilty as charged, I thought silently. SMACK! "FIVE" SMACK "SIX" SMACK "SEVEN" SMACK "EIGHT" SMACK "NINE". Halfway through Sarah's set now. I was somewhat protected by the gym shorts and briefs I was wearing, but Sarah was bigger and stronger than Eva and putting a fair amount into this, so her blows were actually stinging enough to hurt. Still, the idea that Eva was riding me like a cowgirl on a horse while Sarah's hand was all over my bottom was just too delicious for the minimal pain of the spanking to wipe the huge smile off my face.
The next thing caught me completely by surprise. Sarah slipped her fingers into the sides of the waistband on my shorts and into my briefs too and whisked both down just below my knees. "We should have been spanking you on the bare bottom all along! Maybe we'd better start over!". Eva put a stop to that with an intriguing comment: "Just finish up Sarah; we need to move on to the next item." Next item? This evening just kept getting better. I started to fantasize about what this "next item" might be. I was jolted back to reality as Sarah's strong hand hit my now naked behind. SMACK "TEN" SMACK "ELEVEN" SMACK "TWELVE". A new worry came over me. This was coming to an end, and by now I had a raging erection, not so much from the spanking as from the thought of these beautiful girls squeezing my body between their legs and having me in their power. SMACK "THIRTEEN" SMACK "FOURTEEN" SMACK "FIFTEEN" SMACK "SIXTEEN" SMACK "SEVENTEEN". Then she paused, I think just to break the rhythm so I wouldn't know when the last one was coming. SMACK!!!! "OWWW!" "EIGHTEEN!" She really put a lot into that last one, and I was really stinging by now. Still, the smile on my face betrayed me. Eva climbed off me, although I would have been glad if she had stayed. Eva went to help me up, but I just leaned up to get my arms free and I pulled my shorts and briefs back up while I was still face down. "I need a little rest after your cruel punishment." I also needed to not show what effect it had on me. I tried to think about a cold shower but I immediately conjured up a fantasy image of my two sweeties naked in the shower with me. I dropped that idea and I tried to think about baseball. That worked a little better since I'm not really a big fan of baseball.
While I was recovering, lying face down, Eva ran off. In a couple of minutes I dared to sit back up, just as she was returning. The girls immediately sat down on the grass, surrounding me. Eva look more relaxed now; she had seemed nervous about the spanking. She was carrying something in her hand, it looked a little bit like a small black stuffed animal. We all went in the house together and sat together on Eva's couch with me in the middle. Eva took the small furry black thing out of her hand and unfolded it. It was a soft black sleep mask blindfold. It was quite large, and it had black fake fur trim at the edges. It had a couple of elastic straps with velcro adjustments. Eva gently took my head in her arms. "Time for the other half of your present, Charlie; let's get you ready." She took off my glasses and put the blindfold on me and adjusted the straps very carefully so it fit snugly. She made sure the front fit close against my nose and cheeks. Even though it was a bright, sunny day, I was in total darkness. Not only could I not see a think, I couldn't even tell if it was day or night out, except for the warm feel of the sun on my skin.
Sarah spoke next. "Don't forget, Eva, It's my turn to go first on this one." I eagerly awaited whatever they had in store for me. I felt a pair of warm strong arms go around me and pull me toward their owner. It was Sarah. Instinctively I reached out and put my arms around her too. I felt her kiss me gently on the lips and I heard a whispered "one". I felt her lips on mine again. We had all occasionally kissed each other before, but it wasn't anything wild and passionate; more like the way you might kiss your aunt. This one was a good kiss, long and soft and sweet. Sarah took her time. "two" she whispered softly.
I heard Eva get up off the couch and walk out of the room. I sometimes worried about this triangle. Did Eva leave because she couldn't stand to see me kissing Sarah so passionately? I was wild about both of them and I never wanted to do anything that would hurt either of them. Both of them were smart and kind and gentle and beautiful; everything I could ever wish for. My personality meshed better with Eva's; she was more cautious and reserved like me. But Sarah's spontaneity was a lot of fun too. Speaking of Sarah, her lips met mine again for another long sweet kiss. The room was warm and Sarah's kisses were making it warmer. When she got to twelve she took a short break to catch her breath. I took off my T-shirt and tossed it aside.
I heard Sarah do something too, but I wasn't sure what, since I was in total darkness thanks to Eva's super effective blindfold. When we resumed our kissing, I put my arms around Sarah again and pulled her close to my bare chest. I stroked her back and shoulders with my hands, partly for the sheer joy of touching and caressing her and partly to explore what she was wearing now. Her loose T-shirt was gone. On her shoulders I felt the straps of a tank top, along with a set of small bra straps. As I stroked her back I could feel the little bra she was wearing under her tight tank top. Sarah had breasts that were about average size, but rather than fully rounded they were shaped just a little bit more like the cone shaped breasts of a younger girl. Her nipples were a little bit puffy; sometimes she would just wear a tight spaghetti strap top with no bra, and the extra roundness of her nipples would clearly show through. That always turned me on.
It felt nice holding Sarah's soft, beautiful breasts close against my bare chest as we continued to kiss. I heard Eva come back into the room and whisper "fifteen". The last three kisses from Sarah were wonderfully long. I enjoyed them completely. I was looking forward to the next eighteen too, but somehow I didn't expect quite as much from the more proper and reserved Eva. "My turn now!" That was the most assertive I had heard Eva all evening. Sarah gave me one last hug and I heard her get up and walk away.
I immediately found another set of warm loving arms pulling me in as Eva's lips met mine. The first kiss was a bit tentative, but it was still nice. I was expecting to hear "one" but it didn't come. I had put my arms around Eva's waist but I moved my hands up her back and pulled her closer to me as she kissed me again. To my surprise my hands met the bare skin of her shoulders As we kissed I gently stroked her shoulders. A thin strand of fabric was the only thing I encountered. Her loose T-shirt had been replaced by a skin tight spaghetti strap top. I absolutely loved the way these tops looked, but Eva wouldn't be seen in one, unless it was covered by something else. The next kiss was longer and more passionate. She pressed herself tightly to my bare chest. My hands gently stroked her back, partly because she felt so nice and partly because I was curious what she had on now. My gentle caresses were met by nothing but the thin stretchy fabric of her top. She couldn't have been wearing a bra. As our kisses continued I leaned back on the couch and gently pulled her down on top of me. She squeezed herself even closer to me. We didn't bother to count any more, but we kissed passionately for a long time. Finally Eva got back up and gently pulled me up too and took off my blindfold.
As I put my glasses back on, I was overwhelmed by what I saw. Eva usually wore loose T-shirts and jeans, except when she had to dress up for work, and those clothes were not at all revealing either. Now here she was in just a tiny yellow spaghetti strap top. It was tight on her, the fabric was thin, and she was braless. Below, she had on a pair of little yellow short shorts that were also getting too small for her. I couldn't help but ogle her in that cute little outfit. She seemed a little self conscious at first, but took the direct approach. "Like what you see, Charlie? These clothes are old and they're really too small for me now, but I thought you might not mind. Sorry I don't have as much on top to show off as Sarah." "Eva, you're beautiful. I LOVE what I see." She was indeed beautiful. She was a smaller women with smaller breasts and hips, perfectly proportioned in every way. Her breasts were less rounded than Sarah's; they really had the conical shape of an adolescent girl's breasts. Her nipples were very puffy, and they stood out proudly through the thin yellow fabric that was all that covered them. "Do you really mean that, Charlie? Sarah, I've always envied you a little; you're taller and stronger and more athletic and your breasts are fuller than mine." There was no doubt in my mind that the honest answer was the best answer. "Eva, Sarah, you are the two most beautiful women in the world to me. I love everything I see when I look at either one of you. Sure you're different; Eva with your beautiful blond hair and blue eyes and Sarah with your beautiful brown hair and brown eyes. And yes, Sarah, you're tall and Eva is much smaller. And now that Eva has finally been brave enough to show me a little more, yes, your breasts are shaped differently than Sarah's. But that is all wonderful. I'm glad you are different. I wouldn't change either one of you one bit even if I could." That seem to make both Eva and Sarah brighten up. We cuddled in each others arms, glad we had gotten past that.
Then we had a serious talk about something else that was bothering all three of us. We had been the best of friends for quite a while, but none of us had been in "girlfriend/boyfriend" relationships before (with each other or with anyone else). But Eva and I were starting to head in that direction. Eva and I really were falling in love and becoming soulmates, but we were very worried about making Sarah feel hurt or left out. Sarah finally cleared the air with her usual directness. "This was a fun way to celebrate Charlie's birthday, don't you think so, Eva? Especially since it gave you a good excuse to get your hands on your boyfriend's ass." Eva blushed a little and seemed to struggle for something to say, but Sarah continued. "It's OK; I'm very happy for you two. You make a wonderful couple." Eva responded with a bit of directness that was unusual for her. "Sarah, I've been worried about how you would feel; if Charlie and I are becoming boyfriend and girlfriend, you're the odd one who gets left out. That doesn't feel right." I spoke up too. "I've also been worried about you, Sarah. You and Eva are my two best friends in the world, and I love you both and never want to do anything to hurt either of you." Sarah's response surprised us both. "I've been hoping for you two to get together as a couple for a long time. I could see you were made for each other. I'm not at a point in my life where I want a relationship, at least not for a long time. And I don't see any reason the three of us can't still be best friends."
Sarah went on. "The one thing I've worried about is our physical affection. Lately all three of us have been getting a lot more cuddly and touchy-feely. I'm really enjoying that, and I will be disappointed if I'm left out on that. But Eva, I'm also worried that I'll make you feel jealous or hurt if Charlie and I spend too much time pawing each other. Those are my two biggest worries." Eva smiled. "Sarah, if those are really your biggest worries, I feel lots better. I'm fine with you and Charlie pawing each other; it's fun to watch and I'm just not feeling insecure in this relationship.". Sarah turned to me, and asked me in a sarcastic tone "Charlie, I guess we'd better ask you too; can you handle the extra responsibilities of hugging and kissing and pawing me in addition to keeping Eva satisfied? Are you OK with having two women who'll be kissing you and grabbing your ass all the time?" "I think I can handle that." (as if I really needed to answer). Sarah wasn't done. "Eva, I really do need you to think about how you feel. It's best if we go into this up front with a consensus on what kind of boundaries and limits we'll have."
Eva surprised me with her answer. "Sarah, Charlie, I've thought about this a lot. Charlie, obviously you have a right to speak up too, but I know you pretty well and I think you'll be OK with what I have to say. Above all else, I don't want any STDs or unplanned pregnancies for anyone. So we have to be very careful. Charlie, I'd like us to agree now that just assuming, if it happens that we end up in a sexual relationship, we'll use two forms of birth control at all times. Sarah, I'd like our agreement to be that if Charlie and I do end up in a sexual relationship, Charlie only has intercourse and oral sex with me, but other than that I'll be happy to share him with you always. On very special occasions I might even share him with you for EVERYTHING, if it seems like it would be fun for all involved. Are you OK with that, Sarah?" "Eva, that's exactly what I had been hoping for." "Charlie, what about you? Any concerns?" "Eva, Sarah, I love you both more than anything in the world. I feel like the luckiest guy on the planet to even be having this discussion with the two of you."
Eva brought up something else. "We've all been wrestling and play fighting more and more lately. At first I felt uncomfortable with it, but it's actually been a whole lot of fun. Sarah and Charlie, you're both way bigger and stronger than me, so I really don't stand a chance against either of you, but that's OK. You're both so sweet and gentle and wonderful, and I feel really safe when it's one or both of you that overpowers me. And Charlie, I'm getting more and more turned on when you have me pinned down and helpless and I can't escape. When you've got me like that, you're welcome to do more to me than you have been doing. A LOT more. You really don't need to be quite so gentle."
It was getting very late now and the long day had exhausted us. We all went upstairs to Eva's king sized bed. We didn't rush into anything right then, but the three of us fell asleep that night all cuddled up together, full of sweet, sexy dreams of what was to come. It was wonderful.